Monday, December 22, 2014

Remakes For Fun AND Profit

Remake. Reboot. Re-imagining.

These three words are the Robin to Major Hollywood Film Studios' Batman nowadays. I've written on this before, but this is what happens when accountants, not creatives, run things. I've bemoaned them for years,  especially since most of them aren't much more than a re-tread of what has gone before. But when done right (3:10 to Yuma) it can be a real treat (though rare).

When news dropped recently that Chris Pratt was circling a Magnificent Seven remake with Denzel, a light bulb went off in my head about how to do remakes properly. I'm not discussing whether or not they should be done, that is an other post entirely.

The funny thing about The Magnificent Seven being remade is that the original John Sturges film is itself a remake of Seven Samurai. The basic plot is the same, but the Wild West and gunslingers took the place of Feudal Japan and Samurai. This new film isn't going to deviate much from the Sturges film, other than taking place right after the Civil War.

This is exactly what is wrong with remakes. Sure, Denzel is a great actor, and Pratt has shown he can carry a film, but are they Brenner, McQueen and all the other greats of their generation? Doubtful. And why try to copy the formula of a classic? Do you expect this to make a fortune because of the plot and the announced cast? I doubt that will be enough, especially for the fans of the originals.

Instead, there is a way to satisfy the risk mitigating of the suits running these studios and the cinephiles that help these suits make bank.

Why not modernize it a bit? How about instead of cowboys, make it contractors in Iraq or Afghanistan? A village comes to them to get help after a Taliban like group terrorizes the village. There you can make it modern, keep the wild west aesthetic with the desert and have the same story. Could it suck? Of course. As we said, most remakes do. But guess what? I am more intrigued and likely to see it opening weekend rather than catching it at the second-run theater or Redbox. (for the record: I have an idea for a new Magnificent Seven tale in this ilk - as in not a Western).

This would be a way for studios to mitigate risk but banking on a known property while also being creative and bringing something different to the table. For once, everyone can win. And in a world of franchises and superheroes, there is enough bankable product on hand to mitigate this risk.

Ball's in your court Hollywood.

No comments: