I had planned an entry for Back to the Future II (which we will get to), but I've been on a pulp kick lately, and John Carter is a character in that wheelhouse. So let's look at the 2012 Disney "bomb".
Edgar Rice Burroughs' character arrived in the pulp era and along with Tarzan, gave the writer immortality. Naturally, Hollywood has adapted the latter many times (trivia: I have the Star Wars films on tape, recorded when they were on HBO, and a trailer for Greystoke: The Legend of Tarzan aired in front it. How 'bout that?).
The Virginia Cavalryman transported to Barsoom has influenced many an artist, such as filmmakers George Lucas, Jon Favreau and Andrew Stanton.
It was mystery why a John Carter film had a hard time getting made. Back to the Future writer Bob Gale took a stab at a script in the 90s, as did Pirates of the Carribean writers Elliot & Rosso. Jon Favreau had a film in development in the Aughts, but left and made Iron Man instead.
Enter Andrew Stanton, Oscar-winning director of Finding Nemo and Wall-E. Long wanting to make a live-action film, John Carter was a perfect choice for him, and Disney agreed.
I was never really introduced to John Carter as a young buck. Finding out about the film piqued my interest in Carter. The trailer further cemented my interest in the character and the film and I read the first novel.

Kitsch as Carter
The film was very reverent to the source material. Taylor Kitsch was a good choice for the role (not sure whom he beat out, so I can't compare). Dominic West and Mark Strong were solid as usual, and Lynn Collins (as Dejah Thoris) has never looked hotter (she is my home computer wallpaper at present). I won't go far as to say it was as awful as people make it, but a lot of it seemed familiar.
Yes please.
And we have. The film suffered from the literature character's success. Others have shown reverence for Carter in their works. For example, a man transplanted to another world who gains super strength and agility and can leap tall objects in a single bound sounds familiar, doesn't it? Those reverential nods were new in the world of cinema, and done better than in Disney's film. That's why the film barely recouped its budget. That and poor word of mouth did the film in.
The marketing wasn't the greatest either. More hardcore Carte fans, like Michael D Sellers, tell it better than I can. Check out his book.
Perhaps a future generation can make a film that will wow audiences in a way Burroughs did when A Princess of Mars was published. They may also have an appreciation for Stanton's solid effort that was entertaining, if not up to the titular character's legendary status.
No comments:
Post a Comment