Thursday, January 31, 2013

Fan Fiction

I am a writer. Those of you that read this blog know that. You also know I am a cinephile and a geek. I am big into Star Wars, comics, genre shows and books, etc.

As such, I’ve often combined, from time-to-time, these two passions of mine. I’ve written fan fiction screenplays of Star Wars (an epic short film trilogy chronicling the life and times of Jedi Rurik Fel at the dawn of the Empire). I’ve also written a short piece of fan fiction with Lara Croft called The Writer and the Professor.

There is a debate in the world of writing regarding fan fiction. Some authors and intellectual copyright holders are for it, others are against it. And if a particular author/copyright holder is against, they have the right to be and seek damages against those who publish their fan fiction online or other places.

George R.R.Martin, creator of A Song of Fire and Ice, which became HBO’s Game of Thrones, is one such person. As a result, I’ll never write fan fiction or fan films of his work. He has right to think that. It is his work, his creation. I do take umbrage, however, to his reasoning. He says: “But don't write in my universe, or Tolkien's, or the Marvel universe, or the Star Trek universe, or any other borrowed background. Every writer needs to learn to create his own characters, worlds, and settings. Using someone else's world is the lazy way out.”

For those that want to be authors, yes, he is most indeed correct. The same goes if you write spec scripts. But if you want to be a working professional screenwriter, this is wrong. More than half the time now in Hollywood, there are sequels, adaptations and “based on” films. These are existing characters in existing universes. You’re not able to create something new. You have to live in this already established world if you want to get paid. At some point Will Beale created his own universe in a spec, but Gangster Squad was a fictionalized account of real people, and Justice League, which is what he is working on now, is based on some of the most famous comic characters of all time. His success is how he manages these iconic characters/world/situation.

This baffles me because Mr. Martin’s IS A SCREENWRITER of ALREADY ESTABLISHED MATERIAL. He had to live with established material.

Both sides have valid arguments. But such a great author having such a short-sighted view baffles me.

No comments: