I’d like to take this opportunity to discuss something that’s irked me for some time. And before we go further, let’s just say it’s not film related, it’s sports related. So if you don’t care, you may stop reading after the next paragraph.
This past weekend I had a blast shooting Old Scratch with my son and family friend Ashley. My boy was great in front of the camera. He’s a ham, so I didn’t think it’d be an issue. But he hit his marks and didn’t need many extra takes. I am so proud of him. I’m working on getting musicians now, and hope to have it completely finished in one month’s time.
Ok, now onto my rant. I shake my head sometimes at the choices for Most Valuable Players, aka MVPs in sports. I know baseball writers think their shite don’t stink, which is clearly evident to anyone paying attention to the Hall of Fame votes (one writer said that because the initial class, which had Babe Ruth, didn’t have unanimous choices, he wouldn’t vote for anyone on their first trip to the ballot. I’m being serious). Many sportswriters chose their MVP as the best player on the best team. I have three problems with this.
First of all, that is wrong to do in football, because more often than not, that will be the QB. Not that the QB is always undeserving, but in football, so many things have to go right for the QB to do well that singling him out is poor form. Secondly, let’s look at the Patriots in 2008. Tom Brady was out for the year and Matt Cassel who didn’t even start in college, let alone the pros, won 11 games and ha a season worthy of a Pro Bowl bid. That goes to show that you can’t always pick the best player on the best team. Now not too many people can argue Tom Brady’s worthiness (I will later), but they weren’t the best overall team, as they didn’t win the Super Bowl. What happened if there was another team with a 14-2 record and a QB with similar stats (let’s use Atlanta and Matt Ryan as an example). Who do you pick?
Which leads me to point #2. I don’t think you can choose the MVP until the postseason has ended. After all, that is what makes or breaks an MVP, in my opinion. If that was the case, then Brady should not have been MVP. The only sports that end with the regular season are Pro Soccer (everywhere but in the US) and college football (the BCS is NOT a national title system, it’s a series of exhibition games). Every other sport, save baseball, should wait until the playoffs are done. For one thing, that’s when the truly valuable players shine. That’s when stars become legends. Baseball is different because the regular season is the draw. The postseason is gravy. Every other sport is the opposite.
Lastly, the name of the award is MOST VALUABLE PLAYER, not BEST PLAYER. That means that without this individual’s performance, the team would not be as well off as they were. To me, the NFL MVP should have been Peyton Manning. That team was riddled with injuries, and a WR named Blair White went from languishing on the practice squad to an-almost star WR. They won their division when, by all intents and purposes they should’ve been .500. Had Manning been injured they don’t even win 5 games. That’s the definition of MVP.
Baseball got it right in 2006 when they named Ryan Howard MVP over Albert Pujols. Albert was the best player on the best team (who won the World series), but Howard kept the Phillies in the thick of the playoff hunt all year. They wouldn’t have sniffed the playoffs if not for Howard.
If you want to change the name of the award to something that means Best Player on the Best Team, fine. Do that. But until you do, I think it behooves voters to pick someone that changes a team, and without them would suffer a lost season.
After all, that’s what the award is called.
No comments:
Post a Comment