Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Not Completely Down with UP

Thanks to my father-in-law, I have a growing collection of Disney films (I’m not complaining, they’re cool to have. I just need to get Oliver & Company, my fave growing up). He gets them for my kids.

Right now, my daughter’s film du jour is Up, the critically acclaimed, Oscar-winning hit. And rightfully so. This is one of the best animated films I’ve seen in a while. By now it’s obvious that Pixar folks are able to tell great stories and we can all learn from them.

I guess I’ll warn you that there are spoilers involved, but if you haven’t seen it yet, then you must either be living under a rock or in our military, to which I want to say thank you for your service and see this film when you get a chance.

I especially think the first 15-20 minutes are a revelation. They tell the tale of Carl and Ellie’s life together with just pictures and music. There’s no dialogue. You laugh, you say “Wow, that’s my life!” and you cry. Not too many films can do that if they tried (and many do).

When it gets to the adventure part, there are some major problems I have with it and it focuses on believability. When Carl returns home from Ellie’s funeral, we see him getting up the next morning. He gets out of bed and has to crack his joints to get moving. For most of the first third, he needs a cane and can’t go without it. You buy that he’s an older gentleman.

Then when Carl and Russell get to Venezuela, things change. Carl is able to mount and ride a bird, pick up Dug, who looks like a big dog, climb a Zeppelin and hang upside down, and move heavy appliances out of his house. I think of my grandfather in his 70s when I see Carl and there was NO WAY he could do ANY of those things. I can believe Charles Muntz doing them because of the type of person he was, but not Carl.

These things take me out of the movie somewhat, and they get magnified every time I watch. Don’t get me wrong, it’s still an above-average film, but not in the suspension of disbelief apartment.

Aspiring writers and filmmakers, I would suggest getting a copy of the script for the aforementioned first 15-20 minutes. You will learn a lot. And I do look forward to Pixar’s future offerings, while hoping they make them a bit more believable.

No comments: